When the first cold snap arrives, many drivers start wondering whether the tires already on the car are good enough for winter. The answer depends on where you live, how you drive and what kind of tires you have now. Here’s how winter tires and all-season tires really differ, how to read the markings on the sidewall, and how to decide whether a winter set is worth it for you.
What all-season tires are built to do
All-season tires are designed as a compromise. They handle dry roads, wet roads and light snow reasonably well, they last a long time, and they ride quietly. For drivers in mild climates, or in places that only see the occasional dusting of snow that is quickly plowed, they are often all that’s needed.
The trade-off shows up when it gets properly cold. The rubber compound in most all-season tires is chosen to cope with summer heat, and it gets harder as temperatures drop. A harder tire grips less, even on a dry road, and the tread pattern isn’t designed to bite into packed snow or clear slush quickly.
What makes a winter tire different
Winter tires (often called snow tires) are designed for cold, not just for snow. Three things set them apart:
- Softer rubber. The compound is made to stay flexible in freezing temperatures, so the tire keeps conforming to the road surface instead of skating over it.
- Deeper, more open tread. Larger grooves help push slush and water out from under the tire and pack snow into the tread, and snow sticking to snow actually adds grip.
- Lots of sipes. These are the thin slits cut across the tread blocks. They create extra biting edges that help on ice and packed snow.
The result is better starting, steering and especially stopping on snow and ice. All-wheel drive helps you get moving, but it doesn’t help you stop. Tires do that.
How to read the symbols on the sidewall
Two markings cause most of the confusion:
- M+S (mud and snow). You’ll find this on many all-season tires. It describes the tread design and is not a performance test for winter conditions.
- The three-peak mountain snowflake. A snowflake inside a three-peaked mountain means the tire has passed a standardized snow traction test. True winter tires carry it.
Some tires carry both. If you’re shopping for real winter performance, look for the mountain snowflake.
What about all-weather tires?
There’s a newer category in between, usually sold as all-weather tires. They carry the mountain snowflake symbol but are designed to stay on the car all year. They can be a good middle ground for drivers who see regular but not severe winter weather and don’t want to swap tires twice a year. A dedicated winter tire still generally has the edge in deep snow and on ice.
Who really needs winter tires?
Winter tires are worth serious thought if any of these sound like you:
- You live where snow and ice stay on the roads for days or weeks at a time.
- Your local roads are hilly, rural or slow to be plowed.
- You have to drive no matter the weather, for work, school runs or caregiving.
- You regularly drive into the mountains or to ski areas in winter.
- You drive a rear-wheel-drive car, which tends to struggle most on slippery roads.
If you only see a few snowy days a year and can stay home when roads are bad, good all-season or all-weather tires with plenty of tread may be enough. Whatever you choose, our winter driving tips cover how to drive on snow and ice safely.
When to put winter tires on (and take them off)
Because winter tires are about cold as much as snow, don’t wait for the first storm. Many tire makers suggest fitting them once daytime temperatures regularly stay around 45°F (7°C) or below. Tire shops get very busy right after the first snowfall, so booking early helps.
Take them off in spring once temperatures stay mild. The soft rubber wears faster on warm, dry pavement, and you’ll get more seasons out of the set.
Buying tips
- Buy a set of four. Fitting winter tires on only the front or rear axle leaves the car with very different grip front to rear, which can make it harder to control in a slide.
- Stick to your car’s size and load rating, listed on the sticker inside the driver’s door and in the owner’s manual.
- Consider a second set of wheels. Mounting the winter tires on their own wheels makes each seasonal swap quicker and cheaper, and spares your main wheels from salt and potholes. Check that the wheels fit your car and that the tire pressure sensors are sorted out.
- Ask about studs. Studded tires grip well on ice but are restricted or banned in some places and at some times of year, so check your local rules first.
Check tire pressure more often in winter
Cold air takes up less space, so tire pressure drops as temperatures fall, and many drivers see the low-pressure warning light on the first frosty morning. Check pressures when the tires are cold, before you drive, and fill to the figure on the door sticker, not the maximum printed on the tire. A portable tire inflator makes topping up easy at home. Underinflated tires grip less and wear faster, which is the last thing you want in snow.
How to store the off-season set
- Clean the tires and let them dry before storage.
- Keep them somewhere cool, dry and dark, away from sunlight, heaters and electric motors.
- Mark each tire with its position on the car (front left, rear right and so on) so you can rotate them sensibly next season.
Before the first snow
Whichever tires you run, check the tread depth before winter. A simple test is to put a coin in the tread and see how much of it disappears; if the grooves look shallow, have a shop measure them. Pair good tires with a well-stocked car, too: our guide to car accessories for winter covers scrapers, emergency kits and more, and the holiday road trip checklist helps if you’re heading out of town.
FAQ
Can I use winter tires all year?
You can, but it isn’t a good idea. The soft rubber wears quickly on warm pavement and usually gives up some grip and braking in summer heat.
Are winter tires worth it with all-wheel drive?
Often, yes. All-wheel drive helps you accelerate, but braking and cornering grip come from the tires.
Do I need to fit four winter tires?
Yes. Mixing winter tires on one axle with all-seasons on the other can make the car unstable in a slide.
How long do winter tires last?
It depends on mileage, storage and how warm your winters are. Have the tread checked each fall before you fit them.
Top image: A7N8X, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
